Light-controlled pedestrian crossing, Victoria Avenue
Harrogate
Five years after North Yorkshire Council won a million pounds of
active travel funding, we have two light-controlled pedestrian
crossings to show for it.
Two pedestrian crossings on Victoria Avenue - all that is left of
North Yorkshire Council's ambitious Active Travel Fund 2 projects -
are expected to be built between March and July this year.
What else does the council say in its Harrogate & Knaresborough
active travel update?
Mayor of York & North Yorkshire David Skaith has set out his
Vision and Priorities for the region, and says that he intends to
appoint an Active Travel Commissioner.
What else does he say about sustainable transport?
The long-awaited crossings of Oatlands Drive and Wetherby Road have
been delayed again, as North Yorkshire Council carries out its work at
a snail's pace.
A Traffic Regulation Order has been advertised for North Yorkshire's
proposed changes to Victoria Avenue.
Originally, the Active Travel Fund 2 was to pay for four flagship
cycling schemes; now there are none, just the somewhat pathetic
Victoria Avenue pedestrian plan.
Beech Grove, Harrogate, is to get traffic-calming measures as part of
a scheme to make it 20mph. This represents a change to the council's
plans, following speed surveys.
What other active travel updates will be presented at a council
meeting this week?
At a meeting on 30th May, local Councillors agreed to fund the design
of two cycle routes - the missing link from High Bridge, and a Bilton
to Hornbeam Park route.
How much will the designs cost, and how long will they take?
Active Travel England is letting Harrogate cyclists down by
rubber-stamping a lame scheme for Victoria Avenue. The funding bid was
for four ambitious cycling schemes, but now cycling has been stripped
out of the last remaining one.
Why is ATE approving such an unambitious scheme, and what could be
behind its failure to make a difference in North Yorkshire?
North Yorkshire Council have finally got around to launching a
consultation on crossings of Oatlands Drive and Wetherby Road -
crossings which should have been built by the end of this month.
It's early in 2024, but already two Harrogate cyclists have been hit
by drivers in the year so far. This follows on from two other
collisions in December 2023.
North Yorkshire Council is preparing a new Local Transport Plan to
address dissatisfaction with the transport system in the county, and
to attempt to decarbonise transport.
North Yorkshire Council intends to waste £10,000 of public money on
an unwanted cycle signage review in Harrogate & Knaresborough.
Signing was done comprehensively in 2014.
North Yorkshire Council is recommending ten highways projects to
replace Phase 2 of Otley Road Cycleway, and therefore planning a
broken link in the cycle facilities.
What do council officers say in their latest report?
Summary
of key issues in the Oatlands consultation
The results of the Oatlands consultation held back in
October/November 2022 show that most respondents are unhappy with the
way the area is dominated by motor vehicles, and want change.
What are the key issues on and around Oatlands Drive?
Harrogate Station Gateway - originally a hugely positive active
travel and public transport project - has been stripped of most of the
worthwhile elements.
If it goes ahead, it will now largely consist of prettifying the
status quo for pedestrians and prioritising cars with the traffic
light timings on Station Parade.
Misaligned dropped kerb where Slingsby Walk crosses
Oatlands Drive
I recently wrote about Quick Wins suggested by Harrogate Cycle Action
- small improvements to Harrogate's cycle network that could be
implemented quickly and cheaply.
Are there any more examples of Quick Wins? Yes! Here they are.
Demonstration of the inadequacy of the cycle lanes on
Oatlands Drive
Three years into the project to improve Oatlands Drive for active
travel, we're still waiting for the results of the third consultation
which closed nearly a year ago, with a fourth one promised.
Will there ever be any on-the-ground improvements?
All meaningful cycling elements have been stripped out of the West
Harrogate sustainable transport package by the council.
The one positive in the revised package is a 20mph zone, but the rest
is breathtaking cynicism. Is the council just looking for ways to
waste money that it no longer wants?
Andrew Jones MP says the emphasis on sustainable transport in the
Harrogate Station Gateway project is 'welcome', but allocating space
to sustainable travel is not - because it must all be kept for cars.
He supported the project in June, but opposes it in August.
Are Harrogate & Knaresborough Liberal Democrats anti-cycling?
The question arises because they oppose the one and only major local
public realm and active travel scheme, Harrogate Station Gateway.
North Yorkshire Council held a meeting last night to brainstorm ideas
for how to use the Otley Road money they have left after cancelling
Phase 2 of the cycleway. Five years after receiving the funding, they
said, 'it's early days'.
A look at the objections to Harrogate Station Gateway based on ease
of access for shoppers, and whether they amount to a convincing case
against the project.
Councillors of the Harrogate & Knaresborough Area Constituency
Committee gave their conditional support to Harrogate Station Gateway
this morning, despite heckling and jeering from some opponents in the
public gallery.
North Yorkshire Council has cut down around 300 trees at Myer's Wood
for its Kex Gill realignment project. How does this fit in with the
authority's climate strategy?
North Yorkshire made promises at a road safety and active travel
meeting at St Aidan's School on Monday 21st March, including to build
a parallel crossing of Oatlands Drive. Will the council keep its
promises this time?
Highways officers presented an active travel update at a council
meeting today. Inevitably, there were no actual, on-the-ground
improvements to report.
The leader and transport portfolio holder at North Yorkshire County
Council have made a number of commitments to Active Travel England,
including to Gear Change and LTN 1/20. They also specifically pledged
not to remove experimental schemes without evidence.
North Yorkshire County Council is to scrap Otley Road Cycleway Phase
2, despite majority support for it in the most recent consultation.
The same applies to Beech Grove.
North Yorkshire are failing to make any progress on their current
active travel projects, but they continue to make promises about
future active travel schemes. Will those promises ever materialise?
North Yorkshire has published its draft Climate Change Strategy.
Unfortunately it's like homeopathic version of the region's Routemap
to Carbon Negative. Is it so vague that no one will be able to hold
the council to account for its performance, and is that the intention?
The results of the 3rd consultation on Harrogate Station Gateway have
finally been announced. Overall it's good news, with support for the
project increasing since the 2nd consultation.
Harrogate Borough Council's Dragon Road car park was at one time
going to be used for housing. Given its central location, it would
have been a good fit with HBC's rhetoric about 15-minute
neighbourhoods.
Now it appears that parking is going to be prioritised instead of
housing.
N Yorkshire have won a relatively small amount from the Capability
& Ambition Fund. The central purpose of the fund is to develop
active travel expertise in councils across England. Will N Yorkshire
use their allocation to develop in-house expertise?
York & N Yorkshire LEP is boasting about having spent £12 million
on a new road to enable more people from a new housing estate to drive
about a mile to Northallerton town centre. There's no mention of
active travel.
A Slingsby Walk crossing of Wetherby Road is to be discussed at a
council Executive meeting tomorrow. Might this long-discussed crossing
finally be built and if so when?
The Pannal Ash Safe Streets Zone initiative has been presented to the
council, with a public statement to a council meeting and comments by
Councillors.
North Yorkshire is contributing £13 million to an A59 Kex Gill
realignment project, focused on driving to Skipton. Meanwhile the
council is not prepared to commit a single pound of its own money to
active travel projects in Harrogate.
North Yorkshire's 20mph policy is to come under scrutiny at a council
meeting next week. Is the policy just a long list of excuses for
refusing to agree to new 20mph limits?
An upate report on sustainable transport plans for the A61 is to be
discussed at a council meeting next week. Will North Yorkshire County
Council just go round and round in circles commissioning reports, or
will it ever actually DO something?
Victoria Avenue in Harrogate is waiting for its segregated cycle
tracks, but in the meantime it already has some small but helpful bits
of cycle infrastructure.
The York and North Yorkshire region needs to cut car use by 48% by
2030 to achieve its carbon goals. There will have to be a 900%
increase in cycling too.
Burning wood pellets from America at Drax Power Station is not
sustainable, admits the Business and Energy Secretary. York &
North Yorkshire's Net Zero strategy relies heavily on future "negative
emissions" from Drax, so what are the implications for our region?
Graphic from
Emissions Reduction Pathways document
A look at the Emission Reduction Pathways for York & North
Yorkshire, with a special emphasis on transport. How much will private
car use have to be reduced for the region to become Net Zero by 2038?
Harrogate's Active Travel Fund projects on Victoria Avenue and the
A59 Knaresborough Road should have been completed by 31st March 2022,
but no work has started. What has happened to them?
In the last couple of days there has been anonymous briefing against
Harrogate Station Gateway - an £11 million project to improve
Harrogate town centre. This is after it has already been improved. The
project can't be derailed at this stage.
North Yorkshire's bid for money from the third tranche of the Active
Travel Fund (ATF3) has failed. What are the likely reasons behind the
DfT's decision to send the cash elsewhere?
What do the local elections that took place on 5th May 2022 mean for
cycling in Harrogate? I don't know, but I think I've written an
informative article on the subject anyway.
The National Planning Policy Framework says that housing developments
should give priority to active travel, but does Persimmon's King Edwin
Park estate in Harrogate do that?
I noticed someone's interpretation of this crossing facility and
cycle path today. If the designer expects you to do something daft and
inconvenient, do you do it, or do you ignore them?
Destination Harrogate is an organisation that promotes Harrogate
District as a destination for visitors.
What proportion of the District's economy relies on visitors? What
are the priorities in improving Harrogate's appeal, and where does the
Nidderdale Greenway fit in?
Are you on the look-out for a unique and eco-friendly Christmas
present for someone? reCycled gifts are made from bicycle parts that
are no longer needed.
A consultation on detailed designs for Harrogate Station Gateway gets
under way today. The plans are broadly excellent, but there a few
disappointments too.
Widening of Otley
Road at Harlow Moor Road junction
Government guidance says cycle tracks should be created by
reallocating space from motor vehicles. At the junction of Otley Road
and Harlow Moor Road, motor vehicles are getting a lot more space. How
much is left for pedestrians and cyclists?
End of
cycle pavement at Trinity Fields housing development
In theory, new housing development is an opportunity for new and
improved cycle infrastructure. In practice, developers provide a few
bits of joke cycle non-infrastructure.
The metal barrier on Rossett Drive is inconvenient on a normal bike,
and blocks access altogether to non-standard cycles. It's also illegal
under the Equality Act 2010. You'd think it would be removed.
The Otley Road Cycleway project has gone from serial missed deadlines
to a new strategy of providing no timetable at all. Is the new tactic
an improvement on the old, or just as bad but in a different way?
Moord Strookje, or
killing lane, on Oatlands Drive
North Yorkshire has abandoned its plans to make walking and cycling
safer on Oatlands Drive, without even going through with its own
planned consultation.
The representatives of Harrogate's business groups are focused on
'cars, cars, cars', but is this compatible with the changes we need to
make to avoid climate breakdown?
An update on the Otley Road Cycleway - not actual work starting, of
course, but news on the Stray land exchange and Northern Powergrid's
timetable for moving their services.
HAPARA, the Harlow & Pannal Ash Residents' Association, has
produced a report which is supposed to be about sustainable
development. Unfortunately, it dismisses cycling as a solution to
transport problems, and calls for road-building.
The sub-standard painted cycle lanes on Oatlands Drive could be
replaced with proper protected cycle tracks if the county council
succeeds in its bid for funding.
After missing out on half its Tranche 1 bid for Emergency Active
Travel Fund money, North Yorkshire County Council is to consult
community groups over its Tranche 2 bid for £1,065,000.
Chris Batley wrote to the Yorkshire Post objecting to positive
plans for the town centre. I set out the reasons why I don't agree,
and why his arguments don't reflect the facts.
North Yorkshire County Council is so far failing in its active
travel response to the Coronavirus. Widening pavements in a handful
of locations for a single weekend makes no sense when the
virus can be transmitted on any day of the week.
Harrogate District Cycle Action is today launching its new website,
alongside an updated manifesto and refreshed social media accounts.
The website invites local people to sign up as supporters and
contribute their ideas.
What is this
for?...mystery 'cycle infra' at Bellway Pannal development
Can anyone guess the purpose of this 12m long cycle path? It's by
the roundabout at the Bellway housing development, on the old
Dunlopillo site, but it doesn't seem to lead anywhere.
The bid is for a share of the Transforming Cities Fund, which is
money to make it easier, safer and quicker for people to travel and
get to work, by improving transport connections across city regions.
If the bid is successful, part of the money is to be spent in
Harrogate to improve the front of the station, and create better
access for pedestrians and cyclists. It will also be spent on
improved facilities for walking and cycling in the town centre, and
improving public spaces in town.
The bid should be submitted on 28th November 2019.
In a letter to the Yorkshire Post, Bishop Monkton Councillor Brown
claims that 'motorists' are being knocked and made to feel unwelcome
in Harrogate Borough. This is a response to some of his arguments.
A survey by the local MP, to find out what local shoppers think of
the town centre, shows how people get there and what they think of
the cycle facilities.
NYCC published the results of their congestion study, and the
answer from Harrogate and Knaresborough was a resounding 'no' to the
so-called relief road.